It would be more convincing if you were to post links. I am aware of a few experiments where someone gets a degree of comprehension from massive amounts of input. I don’t know the specifics e.g. whether it satisfies fully the Krashen model. I also don’t know how well they learnt the language, my guess is that the result was mediocre with a lack of understanding of grammatical details, but that’s only a guess.
Please refer back to my post where I address each hypothesis.
Learn like a child is an incredibly naive idea. Adults are not children and do not learn in the same way. There are neurological differences and huge environmental differences too. It is well known that children who move to another country or region, where a language other than their L1 is spoken, will learn the new language to a native level as long as they move when young, typically before age 11 give or take a year. A few years older and they usually retain traces of their L1 accent and do not master the grammar. I’ve seen countless examples myself, including a Korean friend who moved to England aged 15, and many friends who moved here before age 11. Adults who make the same move usually struggle to master the new language, and retain a strong accent from their L1. That is empirical proof that we do not learn like children. I can go into the differences if you like, but most people here will be aware of most of them.
What is less well known is that adults can learn a language faster than children, as they are more effective at explicit study. Children learn slowly from context and massive exposure. This assumes that the adult works effectively, most don’t, and even if they do, they rarely speak at a convincing native like level.
I literally stated how to find the studies, as im not into doing leg work for others I’ll just give the author and year of the studies.
Elley, W. B. (1991), Genesee, F. (1987), Crandall, J. (Ed.). (1987), Nagy, W. E., Herman, P. A., & Anderson, R. C. (1985), Day, R. R., & Bamford, J. (1998). and on and on. There is a very large body of evidence, as I said don’t have AI think for you use it to find resources, then evaluate them.
I’m sorry but the studies are out there. Not taking the time to look for them is not the same as them not existing. If you don’t want to read the studies and instead would rather rely on others opinions with no studies to the contrary then go ahead.
Elley 1991, Acquiring Literacy In A Second Language. This is a study of elementary children, so not relevant to our discussion.
The Genesee 1987 reference addresses bilingual education among children so it is not relevant. I cannot find a free copy online and I don’t think you’ve read it.
1987 Crandall addresses ESL Through Content Area Instruction which is a quite separate theory of language learning. So it is not relevant.
Nagy, W. E., Herman, P. A., & Anderson, R. C. (1985) This is a study of school children and their learning of words through written context, They found a small effect. This is not relevant to our discussion.
Obviously you did not read the abstracts and did not read through the papers.
I prefer metastudies and academic textbooks by experts in the field as they can assess papers better than I can. I gave a good example earlier on, and I give it again here for your benefit:
Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching by Richards and Rodgers
The above university textbook documents the better known SLA theories. Suffice to say the authors make it clear that the Krashen theory is simply one theory among many, and it has no special claim to being the theory of SLA. Indeed, they cite zero evidence for it.
Kids should learn languages in school but I agree that the method is ENTIRELY wrong. I will give an example from my own experience.
ZERO foreign language materials were in the classroom. The only materials we had access to were the textbook, and we followed the textbook lessons. The Spanish teacher did not have Spanish language books in her room for example. Same for the French, German, and Japanese teachers. Bookstores, DVD rental places, etc, did not have foreign language materials either - I could not just go down the street and buy a book in a foreign language. It was very different from today (with the internet). There was no way to practice the language unless you just so happened to have relatives who spoke it.
Learning was based on someone’s random decision on what is best to learn first, which is not anywhere near related to what is easiest for my mother tongue to learn first nor what is actually used the most in the language.
A hard focus on memorizing stuff to be correct, on getting test/assignment points, and this was also unnatural language usage (“Would you care for a glass of water?” instead of “You thirsty?”). Zero focus on “as long as you’re understandable it’s ok”.
A teacher who had never lived in any country that spoke the language, also was not married to / friends with native speakers, and had no way of using it in their private life, etc.
Even if you knew native speakers, we were not taught anything we could actually use on a daily basis around the home or in the classroom. Stuff like “My battery is dying”, “We’re out of milk”, and “I need to use the bathroom”. Instead we were taught stuff like “The grass is green” or “Where is the butcher shop?”, when I had never seen a butcher shop in my life.
Then we are told it will take 4 years of this stuff to get to any sort of basic conversational level, so motivation plummets. This is where I heavily advocate for conlangs to be used in schools - there are several which are faster and easier to learn than a natural language however also transfer to immediate comprehension (mutual ineligibility) of natural languages. It’s like easing into the language by learning a special easier dialect and then you have no problems switching to standard language later.
Learning should be focused on what is easiest for a person of that particular mother tongue based on cognates (this could be anything from a news article to a computer magazine), relying on teacher-created materials if required.
The teacher should provide ample materials for the kids to practice the language on, even allowing them to take them home, which has nothing to do with assignments and tests. Their parents are not going to go out and get them stuff.
Kids should just be allowed to do stuff like play on a GBC for 30 minutes in class in Spanish on Mondays. They will learn the language from it and they also need exposure to it in a form that they enjoy. It needs to be real fun stuff, not “eh, it’s better than doing a worksheet”.
With Lingq, I read a chapter of Lord of the Rings in Italian, several Harry Potter books in Greek, am reading Lord of the Flies in Spanish and War of the Worlds in French. Basically, I am reading what I am happy to read anyway.
Comprehensible Input is about reading what you understand but also what you really enjoy (compelling). To be fair, I rely on Lingq translations rather than knowing 95%+ of the second language words.
I have started to mix mini-stories, simple AI texts and proper novels to vary the in-language comprehension, translated supported comprehension and interest. I read 8000 words of Greek (most in ages) yesterday.
I am suggesting this and my other comments as a viable and valid approach.
You took what I said out of context to change the meaning. I did say quite clearly
Perhaps that is why so many learners give up early on. They are bored senseless by a Comprehensible Input approach.
In other words, applying the Krashen CI approach at the beginner level leads to highly tedious and repetitive input.
I doubt anyone would argue with the approach you describe above, but clearly you are not a beginner, and you are in fact much more advanced. It is at that level that we can consume much more interesting input and have a high level of comprehension before we look up words and phrases.
Again I don’t think anyone here would argue against the approach you describe above, except it isn’t CI as described by Krashen. It is a much more sensible method. You study a text, you look up words and phrases, and consume input until it sinks in. I suspect we all, use a variation on that method. You are using graded input with study.
From past discussions, there is general agreement on the forum that if you want to be able to speak +/- fluently, you need to practice.
For clarity, my spoken Greek and partly my unaided reading lags very far behind what I read in Lingq with translations. Basically I want to know most of the vocabulary before very serious attempts at unstructured conversations. I attempt more speech earlier in easier languages. Lingq reading helps me think of words and recognise others in reading amd conversations. The speed of all this varies tremendously across language for me.
My focus on my experience is at least partly to provide a reference etc. others, not just me being self absorbed.
I have heard many people say that the hard part is learning words, and I agree. I find that Grammar tends to fall in place over time and with practice, and there is much less of it compared to vocabulary, at least in French and German. That is not to say that grammar study is not useful of course.
You don’t seem self absorbed, we all have to start from our own experience. Of course we all have to be careful not to assume that our own experience is universal.